5 Written questions
5 Matching questions
- Amendments after filing notice
- 1211.02: Remand to consider a new amendment:
- When should the request for an oral hearing be made?
- How many oral hearing may an applicant request in front of the board
- Appeal process
- a TIME: the request is 2 months from the examiner's initial or supplemental answer (just like other time limits in an appeal), however it can only be extended for good cause (37 CFR 1.136(b)) not automatically.
- b There is no obligation to consider new amendments during the appeal, but: If the amendment is just to cancel claims that are not part of the proceeding, or to re-write dependent claims in independent form (this is important to avoid abandonment in some cases, see below) then the board will remand if there is an amendment.
- c One
- d 1) File notice of appeal within 2 months of final (second) rejection on merits
2) EOT available for up to 3 more months
- e 1) Must be made before jurisdiction passes to the Board
2) Allowed if amendment adopts a suggesion made, or if it removes an issue
3) Not allowed if raises new issues or increases total number of claims
4) Examiner may reopen prosecution to issue a new rejection (from the amendment or based on an IDS filed by applicant)
5 Multiple choice questions
- Appeal procedure within the Office and to the courts has long been provided by stature (35 USC 134)
- Normally once the application is in appeal, the appellant has no right to enter in amendments to the app. However: If the amendment is accompanied by a 37 CFR 1.114 RCE, then the app will go back into prosecution via the RCE along with the amendment.
- If no claims are allowed at all: After the Board's decision the 2 month limit for taking the case to court starts running. After that is over, if there has been no court action the app is abandoned.
THIS IS WHY IT IS IMPORTANT TO PUT DISPUTED DEPENDENT CLAIMS INTO INDEPENDENT FORM: If it turns out that a parent independent claim is not allowed, but that a dependent claim (that has further limitation) would be allowed except for the fact that it is a dependent claim.... the app is still abandoned anyway! (It is up to the applicant to get the claims ready for this eventuality).
When some of the claims are allowed:
There is no requirement to file any further reply, the claims that are allowed will go back to the examiner (most likely to issue, or perhaps to have the examiner request a re-hearing). If there is no reply the other claims will be canceled.
When the claims require further action: (Like in a case where a generic claim rejection is reversed so more work is needed no the claim by the examiner): It just goes back to the examiner for more work.
- 1) Can request rehearing on paper within 2 months from Boards decision
2) Good cause extension of time available
3) Court action must start within 2 months (at least 60 days) from decision
- 1) Examiner must answer within 2 months from receipt of appeal brief
2) MPEP section 1208 recites 11 content requirements
3) No new ground of rejection
4) If new grounds, examiner must reopen prosecution; like a regular office action
5 True/False questions
Terminal Disclaimers → Remember, these are for shortening the life of a claim to that of a pre-existing patent. They are useful in avoiding some double-patenting rejections (like a judicial double patenting rejection).
It must expressly disclaim the terminal part of the patent's term.
IT must state that the patent on the matter will only be enforceable for the limited time period that is disclaimed.
Who has to sign a disclaimer: Either the applicant, the assignee (if assigned in full), applicant & assignee together (for partial assignment), or the atty/agent of record.
1207: The Examiner's Answer to an Appeal Brief: What are the three options an examiner has after reading the appeal brief: → Remember: This can only happen after the Board has issued a rejection, if the Board remands back to the examiner there is no issue that the courts have subject matter jurisdiction over.
TIME: 2 months after the Board's final decision (in case there are re-hearing requests that are in play it is from the final time at which the Board is no longer hearing anything new about the appeal). Extensions are only for good cause.
Failure to provide the appeal brief → 1) Must identify claims being appealed
2) New arguments are allowed but new evidence is not allowed
3) Must traverse all grounds of rejection
4) All claims of a group must stand or fall together, unless stated otherwise
5) If notice of defects issued by PTO, must reply to action being appealed
What do petition matters concern and who deals with them? → Petition matters dealing with objections to formal/procedural matters made to the Commissioner
1214.05: What happens when Claims are Withdrawn from the Appeal: → At this point, the app goes directly back to the examiner, he will either then put all the claims in allowance and get the patent ready for issue, or the examiner may request his own re-hearing (again a 2 month time frame for that re-hearing).