NAME

Question Types


Start With


Question Limit

of 56 available terms

Advertisement Upgrade to remove ads

5 Written Questions

5 Matching Questions

  1. 1214.05: What happens when Claims are Withdrawn from the Appeal:
  2. What statute deals with appeal procedure?
  3. When should the examiner's response arrive and what should it include?
  4. Mandatory appeal conference
  5. When is one in a position to appeal?
  1. a The examiner's answer should come within 2 months of the receipt of the brief by the examiner and should contain:

    responses to arguments in the brief and point out errors in the brief.

    If the appeal is persuasive the examiner should also expressly withdraw his rejection on grounds where the appeal was persuasive.
  2. b In order to even have an appeal available the USPTO has to have issued a second rejection on a claim. The second rejection could either be a normal final rejection, or it could be a rejection where the claim was initially rejected in the original app, a CIP/CPA/RCE was filed to continue the app, and then the same claim was rejected in the continuation (1 time original + 1 time continuation == 2 rejections).
  3. c There is a mandatory appeal conference when a valid appeal brief is filed. It has: the main examiner for the app, the supervisory patent examiner, and a conferee examiner who is experienced in the area that the patent covers.
  4. d Appeal procedure within the Office and to the courts has long been provided by stature (35 USC 134)
  5. e Say there are 3 disputed claims, but the appellant either does not argue for some of them on appeal or withdraws arguments for some of them. If 2 of the 3 claims are allowed by the Board (reversing the examiner) and the third claim is considered withdrawn since it is not argued, then the 2 reversed claims go into allowance, and the non-argued claim is now canceled by the appellant's acts.

5 Multiple Choice Questions

  1. These are where the patentee expressly disclaims 1 or more claims in the patent. This is usually due to losing a lawsuit or something along those lines.
  2. These are only considered when the appellant makes the showing under 37 CFR 1.116(c) as to why the affidavits are necessary, and as to why they were not presented earlier.
  3. 1) After 2 months from the time of the examiner's answer/supplemental answer if the applicant does not file a reply brief to that answer; or
    2) If the applicant did file a reply brief, after the examiner notifies the applicant that the reply brief has been entered & considered and that the appeal will go to the board.
  4. 1.REOPEN THE PROSECUTION and enter in a new ground for rejection (as long as this is approved by his supervising examiner).
    2. WITHDRAW THE FINAL REJECTION and allowing the claims (when the appeal overcomes the grounds for rejection). or;
    3. MAINTAIN THE APPEAL by drafting an examiner's answer that will go along with the appeal brief to the board. After 20040913 this brief may also contain new grounds for a rejection too.
  5. 1) Can request rehearing on paper within 2 months from Boards decision
    2) Good cause extension of time available
    3) Court action must start within 2 months (at least 60 days) from decision

5 True/False Questions

  1. 1213: What Decisions the Board may Make:The board can reverse the examiner's rejection, affirm it in whole or in part, or remand. Remember, that for a later court case, that a decision to remand cannot be brought up for judicial review (only an affirmation of the rejection).
    1213.01: The Board may simply state how the applicant could amend an appealed claim such that it would be allowed. The applicant may then properly amend the claim within the time period for seeking court review (that is a 2 month window starting from the date of the board's final decision).
    1213.02: New Grounds for Rejection: the Board can make a rejection on new grounds for any claim it wants to. (even if the claim was not previously rejected). Remember, this is different than the examiner who can only reject a claim on new grounds if he had already rejected the same claim for different reasons (an examiner it not allowed to find a new ground to reject a claim he previously put into allowance).

          

  2. 1214.04: What happens when the Examiner is Reversed in full:At this point, the app goes directly back to the examiner, he will either then put all the claims in allowance and get the patent ready for issue, or the examiner may request his own re-hearing (again a 2 month time frame for that re-hearing).

          

  3. What are two examples of time limit situations for filing an appeal?Say there is a final office action (3 month SSP), and the applicant files notice to appeal within 1 month of the office action. If the applicant fails to submit his actual appeal brief within 2 months of the notice, but still gets it in before the original SSP. Then the applicant still has to file a petition for a time extension. (Same thing can happen with an RCE, if the RCE is filed > 2 months after the office action, but before the 3 month SSP, a petition for a 1 month extension is needed).

          

  4. What is required to be in appeal brief?One important caveat: Remember that when filing an RCE after a final rejection the applicant has a choice: Either appeal, or file the RCE. By filing an RCE the applicant is agreeing not to file an appeal, at least until the claim is rejected under the RCE itself. So even if there are 2 rejections in the original app, when the applicant files an RCE he is waiving the appeal until there is another rejection.

          

  5. 1211.02: Remand to consider a new amendment:1) The examiner's supplemental answer may have new grounds for rejection of a claim if it is in response to the board sending the app back for further consideration.
    2) Whenever the examiner makes a supplemental answer (even if it does not have new grounds for rejection) the applicant must file one of these forms of response to avoid having the appeal dismissed:
    1. Reopen prosecution on the claim, this is the normal 37 CFR 1.111 response to a rejection and it can also have the 37 CFR 1.130/1.131/1.132 affidavits & evidence accompanying the response.
    2. Maintain the appeal: By filing a brief (37 CFR 41.41) the appeal can be kept going after the remand & supplemental response.

          

Create Set