Create an account
How is Inter Partes Reexammination Different from Ex Partes Reexamination
Different in 7 ways:
1. applicable only to patents issuing from apps filed on or after 11/29/99
2. if requestq is granted, first OA is mailed with the order granting request
3. if request is denied, partial refund
4. no interviews are permitted during inter parts reexam
5. 3rd party requestor may respond to patent owner's reply to each OA
6. 3rd party requestor may appeal to the Board or participate in patent owner's appeal Board
7. a party who has previously requested an inter partes reexam in which a final decision favorable to the patentability of a claim is estopped from later Court action on the basis of issues raised or issues that could have been raised in the inter partes reexam
Who may not request Inter Partes Reexamination?
1. the patent owner
2. party who previously lost in a court action on a validity challenge to the patent on the basis of issues raised or issues that could have been raised
3. a party who has previously requested an inter partes reexam which has been granted and is still pending
4. a party who has previously requested an inter partes reexam in which a final decision favorable to the patentability of a claim was made on the basis of issues raised (or could have been) on previous request
Request for, and Service of, Inter Partes Reexamination
Essentially the same as ex parte reexam except includes rule 1.20(c)(2) fee of $8,800--no small entity; certification that R907 estoppel does not apply, and must identify the real party who is making request
3rd Party Requestor Participation in Inter Partes Reexamination
1.3rd party requestor may file wriiten comments, once, to patent owner's reply to each OA
2. Must be filed within 30 days of receiveing service of patent owner's reply to OA
3. no EOT
4. written comment (50 max) must be limited to issues raised in OA & reply
5.citations of additional prior art are limited to those necessart to respond to patent owner's reply and issues raised by examiner in OA
Strict 9 Step Appeal Procedure
1.appeal brief - due two months from notice of appeal
2.respondent's brief- due one month from service of appeal brief
3.examiner's answer: no new grounds fro rejection (or reopen pros)
4. rebuttul brief- due one month from examiner's answer
5.request fro oral hearing-due 2 months from examiner's answer
6 oral arguement-20 mins for examiner and 30 mins for each partyt
7. decision by Board
8. petition for rehearing due one month from initial decision
9. appeal to federal circuit by patent owner
What happens if there are multiple reexams?
y may be merged or one proceeding suspended until the other concludes; if inter partes merged with ex parte reexam, inter partes rules govern, but ex part requestor get no additional rights, and one reexam certificate will issue
Commissioner is empowered to suspend one proceeding until the other is concluded
may be merged or one proceeding suspended until the other concluded; if merged with reissue, inter partes rules govern, but requestor can participate; identical papers filed and same claims must be pending in both files, and reissue patent also serves as the reexam certificate
Please allow access to your computer’s microphone to use Voice Recording.
Having trouble? Click here for help.
We can’t access your microphone!
Click the icon above to update your browser permissions and try again
Reload the page to try again!Reload
Press Cmd-0 to reset your zoom
Press Ctrl-0 to reset your zoom
It looks like your browser might be zoomed in or out. Your browser needs to be zoomed to a normal size to record audio.
Please upgrade Flash or install Chrome
to use Voice Recording.
For more help, see our troubleshooting page.
Your microphone is muted
For help fixing this issue, see this FAQ.
Star this term
You can study starred terms together