19 terms

Alexander II Historians

IB History, historians views and quotes
STUDY
PLAY
John Grenville - emancipation of the serfs
Nothing more than a cruel joke
Hugh Seton Watson - reforms: success/failure
Tried to reach the best between two worlds but failed as he tried to reach an unreal compromise between autocracy and modern reforms
Richard Pipes - emancipation
'After 1861 the economic situation of the Russian peasantry deteriorated and in 1900 he was by and large worse off than he had been in 1800'
Sam Olofsson - reason for modernisation
His need to modernise came from his need to establish autocratic rule.
W Bruce Lincoln - extent of reform
By the end of Alexander II's rule the state and the autocracy was in no way changed, the tsar still had total power.
A J Rieber - purpose of reforms
Alexander was motivated solely by military reasons and the desire to strengthen the state through a strong modernised army
More interested in the maintenance of the autocracy than actual reforms.
Larissa Zakharova - principals
Alexander was an autocratic in both his principals and his actions
G Stevenson - political change
'nothing Alexander did alter was intended to alter the fundamental political fact of a god created autocracy'
H Seton Watson - legal reforms
The courtroom was the one place in Russia where real freedom of speech prevailed.
H Seton Watson - reforms
Tsardom never reformed unless there was a pressure from a war.
Westwood - success
Despite imperfections the emancipation program was an enormous step forward and no Russian ruler brought so much relief to so many
Tim Chapman - emancipation
'The single most important law or decree issued by any Tsar in nineteenth century Russia'
David Saunders - personality
Personal weaknesses - little understanding or control over his own reforms and the laws
Crankshaw - emancipation/maintenance of the regime
'The emancipation had to be he knew it but he did not like it'
David Christian - emancipation
"Emancipation was a success at achieving its immediate objectives" peasant disturbances were reduced and serfdom was abolished without provoking an immediate rebellion
A J Rieber - zemstvo
It was designed with the interest of nobility at heart.
Richard Pipes - emancipation
'Too cautious, too little, too late'
David Saunders - education
Education reforms grew student radicalism and teaching lectures appeared to be serving not only academic and economic purposes but also the promotion of political instability
David Saunders - emancipation
'A severe critic of the statutes of 1862
Might respond to the questions why did Alexander the II free the serfs by saying he failed to do so?'
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE...