Related questions with answers

Analyze Riley's essay (W. B. Riley, “The Faith of the Fundamentalists,” ) to see how he creates a fundamentalist identity in opposition to modernism. What definition of each emerges from his discussion?

More than 600,000 immigrants passed through Ellis Island in 1912, the year residents of the Lower East Side wrote this letter to President Taft criticizing the disparaging remarks of the New York commissioner of immigration. Unlike earlier waves of immigration, increasing numbers hailed from Southern and Eastern Europe, including Jews and other groups that many Americans feared as radical and inassimilable. This anxiety led to a study published in $1911$ by the Dillingham Commission recommending immigration restriction, which would later be enacted in the early $1920$ s. Here, a citizens' committee of the Lower East Side responds by affirming their identity as Americans.

Examine the role of ethnic identity in shaping both the Commission of Immigration's characterization of Lower East Side residents and their response. To what extent did their ethnicity define them in their own minds?

Question

Why do you think Kallen set "democracy" against "melting pot" in his title? How does he define the relationship between these ideals?

Solution

Verified

Answered 2 years ago

Horace Kallen contended in the early twentieth century that the idea of the "melting pot" did not and should not represent American cultural history. Kallen, on the other hand, argued for cultural awareness, in which diverse groups may preserve their cultural legacy while respecting the links and aspirations of everyone else. Throughout the twentieth and twenty-first decades, this ideal has been put to the test, notably by organizations that desire to stay fundamentally distinct from the American population, such as the Amish.